Excelsior Fund Seeks The Decelerated
Monday, March 31st, 2008It’s not just about making money it’s about keeping it.
Doug Pyle, a managing director who heads up $850 million Excelsior Small Cap Fund, finds that most investors are more concerned about losing money than about making more.
And since just a few bad calls can sink a portfolio, he takes pains to keep blowups to a minimum.
“There are always four or five stocks that have the unique ability to corrode everything,” he said.
To reduce the chance of hitting land mines, Pyle seeks out stocks that are unfairly beaten down. Their downside already has been cut.
A company’s historical performance helps Pyle figure out whether it’s downtrodden or flying high. He looks at price-to-book value, price to sales, and the operating margins of a company. For most companies, those numbers will have a certain range over time.
“If some stock has a history of whatever price-to-book ratio, and it’s way below that, it usually can’t go down much further,” he said.
When a stock seems to have bottomed out, that is the time to buy, he says, because whatever bad news or events have pushed it down have already happened.
Pyle will pass on stocks with a debt-to-capital ratio greater than 50%. The average in the portfolio is about 20%. Stocks must also have market caps of less than $1.5 billion to be considered.
He also doesn’t like to listen to conventional wisdom. To insulate himself from that, he gathers his own information, avoiding many popular services that offer earnings estimates, for example.
That’s also what helps him get to stocks before anyone else does.
Pyle says he also looks at larger trends that might help a given stock.
A lack of market volatility was one reason to buy GFI Group, () an interdealer derivatives brokerage, last summer. It was trading at about 50 and the stock had suffered a steep price decline. It had topped out in May 2006 at about 66. By August it had bottomed out at 45.
Earnings Estimate
But Pyle looked at the book value of the company, and then at what it could earn. He came up with a figure of $4 per share per year, based on earning 20% on the book value of the company. He took a 3% position in the stock. It now makes up 3.6%.
He also noted that only a small percentage, about 5%, of brokerage transactions were hedged in any way. The equity and bond markets, up to that point, had a relatively low volatility.
GFI Group would benefit from a period of higher volatility, and a low-volatility market could not last forever, Pyle held.
As volatility in the market increased during the last half of 2007 and 2007, GFI Group’s stock went with it. It’s now trading at about 83.
Pyle will also jump on tech trends. Flir Systems () designs infrared detection equipment used in motion detectors and targeting systems. When Pyle added it to the fund in May 2006, it had suffered and was trading in the 20s.
That was largely because the earnings were depressed by a single manufacturing plant in Boston that wasn’t operating efficiently.
But Pyle thought the company would turn things around. Flir introduced new products and got supply contracts with the military.
Earnings went from a 10% decline in the second quarter of 2006 to double- or triple-digit growth for the next four quarters.
The stock has gone on a steady tear and closed Oct. 12 at just under 60, and now makes up about 3% of the fund.
Limits On Stakes
The fund holds 40-50 stocks. Pyle doesn’t let positions get past 6%. A stock stays in the fund about three years on average.
He starts positions at anywhere from 1% to 3%, the latter being as much as he will buy at once.
When Pyle decides to sell, it’s usually because the stock has reached a point above its historical price-to-book value.
He does have some price targets, though they are contingent on changes in the business and in the market conditions as a whole.